Browse All Lighthouse Hill NY Properties for Sale

A Very special home with a dynamite location. Home was previously a 2 family side by side converted to an outstanding one family. Words may not accurately depict how you will feel when you pull up in front and take that first step into the one you may have been waiting for. Preview privately by appointment.

116-118 Mace Street, Staten Island

$1,100,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1160323 MLS

Located in prestigious Lighthouse Hill this oversized Center Hall Colonial offers space for multiple generations to live in and enjoy. Surround yourself with natures beauty in abundance on meticulously maintained 80x107 grounds. The main living area is expansive and charming with hardwood floors throughout and features a large living room with fireplace, a 3/4 bathroom, a formal dining room opening directly into the kitchen, a tremendous family room that has pocket doors leading into an additional room. Upstairs there are 4 large bedrooms all with ample closet space, and two full bathrooms. Both bathrooms are recently renovated. There is a two car garage , and a finished basement with a ground level entrance. This home offers many possibilities and room for everyone. Pack your bags, the only thing missing is you!

83 Meisner Avenue, Staten Island

$499,999

1160024 MLS

Rare opportunity to purchase a shovel ready lot on prime Lighthouse Hill. Sewered lot. Previously approved for a 4,000 square foot home plus basement, 2-car garage, elevator, & in-ground pool. Beautiful setting and view! (Labeled as 'Plan A') in pictures owner then had the planned house down sized. (Labeled as 'Plan B') in pictures the house can be built either way. The reason this is such a rare opportunity and great opportunity is that Lighthouse Hill, as well as the other hills are designated Natural Areas and routinely take several years to get approved, also they are very costly to get approved. This is priced to sell!!

387 Lighthouse Avenue, Staten Island

$648,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1159902 MLS

An Amazing opportunity to own this Single family home in Lighthouse Hill. Situated on a 5000sf lot offering a lot of different potential, including building your own dream home! Property also comes with a 10k sf lot in the back of the home (see pics). 1st flr - Living room, Dining area, Eat in kitchen. 2nd flr - 4 bedrooms, 1 full bath. Unfinished basement. Private driveway.

3429 Richmond Road, Staten Island

$1,575,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1159799 MLS

Welcome to your private paradise. Kick your shoes off and move right in to This custom built 5200 square foot 5 bedroom 5 bath luxury home. The custom kitchen will excite your inner chef while you entertain your guests in this magnificent open floor plan with 10ft ceilings complete with a party room with DJ Booth and countless amenities. Much attention to detail when this home was designed from Hardwood flooring, porcelain tiles, 7 zone radiant heat, central air, finished basement with bar and theatre, tons of closets and storage. 2 car garage, Resort like backyard with heated in ground pool ,outdoor kitchen , pizza oven, walk out basement and wine cellar property, in ground pool.

437 Lighthouse Avenue, Staten Island

$1,799,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1158910 MLS

Situated on the foot of prestigious Lighthouse Hill is a magnificent 4000+ square foot, five bedroom home steeped in luxury. Double door entry leads to a soaring and dramatic foyer showcasing over the top attention to detail with a jaw dropping chandelier as its centerpiece. French doors on either side open to a banquet sized formal dining room on the right and an elegant formal sitting room to the left both sporting refinished oak flooring with real Osh-Kosh decorative trim. Crown, wall and baseboard moldings are intricate yet tasteful. Center-hall configuration provides traditional room layout while offering a phenomenal flow for entertaining. The palatial eat in kitchen is updated throughout. Professional appliances, restaurant tier Viking stove/oven, limestone countertops, oversized island breakfast bar plus butler's hall with wetbar leading to the formal dining room. Pocket doors take you into the great/family room complete with custom fireplace and two (2) sets of French doors to the rear Trex-deck. Additional main level amenities include updated half bath powder room, double coat closets, and 4 zone radiant heat under all surfaces, including oak floors. Second level features primary suite with two (2) custom, cedar lined walk-in-closets, all new private bath complete with clawfoot soaking tub, separate shower with steam feature, two (2) vanities and separate radiant heat zone. Three additional guest rooms, all with custom double closets, separate heating zones plus all new full bathroom and second level laundry as an added convenience. Fully finished lower level boasts better than 9 foot ceilings, fifth (5th) bedroom or movie theater, all custom tiling, recreation room with fireplace and half bath plus custom sauna room with shower, a feature rarely found in homes today. Mud room off garage features all custom cabinetry for shoes and jackets. Over the top custom 2 garage with Viking professional refrigerator, dry age meat locker, butcher block counter tops,

61 Mace Street, Staten Island

$980,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1158203 MLS

Step into this elegant single family home in prestigious Lighthouse Hill. The open floor plan features a modern kitchen with top of the line appliances, custom stone-built wood burning fireplace ,super large sliding door to a huge country like garden & yard with patio and BBQ for entertaining .Set up as 2 bedrooms-was originally 3.Can be converted back.2 car built in garage plus driveway leads to full, finished basement. Convenient to the SI Mall ,desired New Dorp Lane with exclusive shops & restaurants. After shopping and dining, relax on the front porch with a beverage of choice. A must see-a home to be proud of

67 Meisner Avenue, Staten Island

$550,000

1158184 MLS

LARGE LAND FOR SALE. MOST SOUGHT AFTER NEIGHBORHOOD - LIGHTHOUSE HILL. SELLER PLANS TO PROVIDE APPROVED PLANS TO BUYER. ONE FAMILY HOME 2,352 SQ FT. BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME. TWO LOTS AVAILABLE.

40 Aultman Avenue, Staten Island

$800,000

1158182 MLS

LARGE LAND FOR SALE. MOST SOUGHT AFTER NEIGHBORHOOD - LIGHTHOUSE HILL. SELLER PLANS TO PROVIDE APPROVED PLANS TO BUYER. ONE FAMILY HOME 2,352 SQ FT. BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME. TWO LOTS AVAILABLE.

46 Aultman Avenue, Staten Island

$775,000

1156463 MLS

Land for sale with approved plans. The most sort after neighborhood, top of Lighthouse Hill with views of the harbor and N.J. You will feel like you're in the country. Fully approved to build 3,500 SF home + 1,500 SF basement= 5,000 SF of house. Walk-out basement creates the 3rd level of living space. 10ft ceilings on every floor. 4 bedrooms each with their own bath. Total of 6 bathrooms. Build your dream home. Two lots are available.

280 Edinboro Road, Staten Island

$2,300,000

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1153345 MLS

Built in 1856 & Landmarked in 2007 The Nathaniel J. and Ann C. Wyeth House sits on a beautiful 32000 sf. lot. Renovate this masterpiece; enjoy the scenery & solitude or subdivide this property. Architectural survey will be provided upon request. Subject to E&O. CASH offers only!

190 Meisner Avenue, Staten Island

Lighthouse Hill Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Lighthouse Hill and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!