Sign up to stay up to date on the Tottenville Home Values!

or Create your own market report
Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
158 Carteret Street 4 2 1,850 $819,000 $442 3 days
382 Sprague Avenue 2 1 1,188 $469,000 $394 4 days
4949 Arthur Kill Road N/A N/A N/A $1,699,900 Unknown 6 days
240 Page Avenue N/A N/A 64,167 $550,000 $8.57 5 days
129 Satterlee Street 4 5 2,700 $1,269,000 $470 5 days
51 Forest Lane 3 3 1,150 $575,000 $500 7 days
667 Rockaway Street 4 3 2,000 $889,000 $444 7 days
80-82 Craig Avenue 6 5 3,088 $1,395,000 $451 10 days
354 Sleight Avenue 4 2 1,313 $699,000 $532 12 days
552 Rockaway Street 4 2 1,696 $699,000 $412 14 days
425 Loretto Street 3 3 2,232 $899,999 $403 19 days
148 Aspinwall Street 4 3 3,444 $1,200,000 $348 18 days
153 Johnson Avenue 6 4 2,720 $999,999 $367 19 days
39 Blossom Lane 3 3 2,000 $850,000 $425 21 days
327 Brehaut Avenue 3 5 2,400 $999,000 $416 25 days
60 Carteret Street 4 3 2,210 $949,999 $429 35 days
5297 Arthur Kill Road 7 4 2,192 $1,599,999 $729 37 days
5295-5297 Arthur Kill Road 7 3 2,192 $1,599,999 $729 43 days
150 Barnard Avenue 3 2 1,360 $775,000 $569 41 days
238 Main Street N/A N/A N/A $315,000 Unknown 45 days
18 Jeffrey Place 4 4 6,600 $2,795,000 $423 49 days
11 Newfolden Place 5 4 4,608 $1,869,000 $405 52 days
7550 Amboy Road 6 5 2,816 $1,229,000 $436 54 days
7546 Amboy Road 6 5 2,700 $1,198,000 $443 54 days
271 Barnard Avenue 3 2 1,020 $599,999 $588 63 days
426 Loretto Street 3 3 3,975 $1,388,888 $349 63 days
174-176 Camden Avenue 9 4 3,000 $1,550,000 $516 69 days
176 Camden Avenue 3 3 1,500 $825,000 $550 67 days
7126 Amboy Road 3 4 3,750 $1,100,000 $293 77 days
142 Butler Avenue 2 1 1,152 $549,999 $477 81 days
4916 Arthur Kill Road Unit 5 N/A N/A 4,428 $6,000 $1.35 84 days
558 Main Street 4 4 3,500 $1,199,999 $342 88 days
101 Bedell Avenue 4 5 3,540 $1,490,000 $420 91 days
35 Amaron Lane 6 6 4,800 $1,799,999 $374 97 days
174 Camden Avenue 3 3 1,500 $725,000 $483 95 days
631 Yetman Avenue 3 3 1,500 $710,000 $473 103 days
7075 Amboy Road 5 5 4,350 $1,250,000 $287 103 days
336 Bethel Avenue 4 4 2,000 $999,888 $499 103 days
25 Sanford Street 4 5 2,720 $1,299,999 $477 111 days
21 Sanford Street 4 5 2,720 $1,299,999 $477 111 days
315 Main Street 3 3 2,049 $949,000 $463 150 days
188 Lee Avenue 4 4 2,880 $1,388,000 $481 140 days
334 Bethel Avenue 5 5 3,720 $1,199,888 $322 157 days
Minerva Avenue N/A N/A N/A $449,000 Unknown 166 days
7069 Amboy Road 5 5 4,143 $1,179,987 $284 185 days
127 Surfside Plaza 1 1 594 $255,900 $430 198 days
5461 Arthur Kill Road 4 2 2,142 $499,000 $232 206 days
217 Main Street N/A N/A 18,750 $31,500 $1.68 203 days
3 Craig Avenue 4 4 2,400 $963,000 $401 229 days
287 Main Street 6 5 3,000 $1,275,000 $425 231 days
Average: 4.1 3.5 4,113 $984,490 $436 108 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 57
Viewing 1 - 50 of 57
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
357 Brehaut Avenue 4 2 2,250 $899,999 $399 6 days
158 Chelsea Street 3 1 1,092 $699,999 $641 11 days
129 Pittsville Avenue 2 2 600 $594,000 $990 30 days
5315 Arthur Kill Road 6 3 1,964 $899,900 $458 35 days
5315 Arthur Kill Road 8 3 1,964 $899,900 $458 35 days
240 Page Avenue N/A N/A 1,300 $139,000 $106 80 days
273 Nashville Street Unit A 6 5 2,908 $1,300,000 $447 93 days
340 Bethel Avenue 5 5 4,107 $1,199,799 $292 185 days
137-139 Barnard Avenue N/A N/A 8,624 $1,550,000 $179 221 days
7382 Amboy Road Unit D 3 3 1,233 $319,000 $258 390 days
344 Bethel Avenue 5 5 4,143 $1,200,000 $289 423 days
Average: 4.7 3.2 2,744 $881,963 $411 137 days
Viewing 1 - 11 of 11
Viewing 1 - 11 of 11
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
252 Bethel Avenue 4 3 2,081 $1,148,000 $1,167,500 $561 81 days 9/29/23
31 Eden Court 3 2 1,350 $529,999 $539,000 $399 104 days 9/25/23
15 Eden Court 3 2 1,440 $549,000 $535,000 $371 46 days 9/22/23
35 Nancy Lane 6 4 4,400 $1,200,000 $1,125,000 $255 240 days 9/21/23
291 Richmond Valley Road N/A N/A N/A $4,000,000 $3,500,000 Unknown 366 days 9/19/23
440 Sleight Avenue 4 4 2,450 $1,125,000 $1,125,000 $459 129 days 9/15/23
35 Bocce Court 5 4 2,700 $999,800 $1,045,000 $387 112 days 9/14/23
107 Patten Street 4 2 1,872 $799,000 $750,000 $400 61 days 9/12/23
217 Brighton Street Unit A 5 4 2,538 $989,990 $950,000 $374 82 days 9/12/23
26 Sandy Lane 3 3 1,104 $550,000 $535,000 $484 108 days 9/8/23
233 Yetman Avenue 7 5 4,131 $1,099,999 $995,000 $240 195 days 9/7/23
457 Brighton Street 3 4 2,184 $898,000 $880,000 $402 165 days 9/1/23
711 Craig Avenue 3 3 2,280 $849,999 $830,000 $364 88 days 9/1/23
269 Brighton Street 3 2 2,376 $749,999 $745,000 $313 218 days 8/31/23
384 Main Street 3 2 1,183 $749,500 $735,000 $621 131 days 8/30/23
315 Ellis Street 3 4 2,647 $959,000 $930,000 $351 128 days 8/30/23
7372 Amboy Road 3 3 1,800 $599,900 $560,000 $311 196 days 8/29/23
20 Sandy Lane 3 3 1,100 $559,000 $540,000 $490 214 days 8/28/23
158 Surfside Plaza 2 2 1,188 $429,000 $429,000 $361 127 days 8/25/23
457 Craig Avenue 3 2 1,279 $559,000 $535,000 $418 97 days 8/23/23
116 Bedell Avenue 2 2 1,336 $699,000 $640,000 $479 349 days 8/21/23
7251 Amboy Road 3 2 1,497 $499,000 $460,000 $307 506 days 8/21/23
24 Bedell Avenue 4 4 3,178 $1,400,000 $1,380,000 $434 125 days 8/16/23
28 Bedell Avenue 4 4 3,178 $1,400,000 $1,375,000 $432 449 days 8/15/23
588 Main Street 3 2 2,400 $784,999 $750,000 $312 323 days 8/10/23
38 Sandy Lane 3 3 1,000 $569,000 $554,000 $554 261 days 8/3/23
50 Girard Street 2 3 1,800 $538,888 $500,000 $277 112 days 8/2/23
182 Brehaut Avenue 3 3 1,600 $539,789 $560,000 $350 84 days 8/1/23
7481-7485 Amboy Road 6 4 3,289 $1,050,000 $950,000 $288 487 days 7/14/23
15 Forest Lane 3 3 1,100 $539,900 $527,500 $479 171 days 7/10/23
223 Bedell Avenue 4 3 3,200 $1,195,000 $1,125,000 $351 148 days 7/10/23
120 Tyrrell Street 3 3 2,800 $849,000 $820,000 $292 102 days 7/7/23
382 Loretto Street 4 3 2,700 $900,000 $830,000 $307 120 days 7/6/23
488 Butler Boulevard N/A N/A N/A $750,000 $750,000 Unknown 253 days 7/5/23
44 Fayann Lane 5 3 3,400 $1,398,000 $1,345,000 $395 161 days 7/5/23
108 Surfside Plaza N/A 1 564 $219,000 $205,000 $363 256 days 6/30/23
No address 4 4 3,400 $1,499,000 $1,450,000 $426 273 days 6/30/23
149 Satterlee Street 3 2 1,996 $989,900 $950,000 $475 257 days 6/26/23
260 Wood Avenue 3 2 1,188 $575,000 $575,000 $484 259 days 6/23/23
551 Rockaway Street 4 5 2,450 $1,039,000 $999,999 $408 284 days 6/20/23
7379 Amboy Road 3 3 3,060 $1,250,000 $905,000 $295 197 days 6/14/23
110 Joline Avenue 3 2 1,488 $845,000 $787,500 $529 86 days 6/12/23
214 Cheevers Lane 4 4 3,010 $1,299,000 $1,238,000 $411 219 days 6/9/23
35 Sprague Avenue 3 4 2,060 $965,000 $915,000 $444 83 days 6/7/23
214 Chelsea Street 3 3 2,700 $1,275,000 $1,275,000 $472 68 days 6/5/23
184 Sprague Avenue 5 4 2,570 $849,900 $825,000 $321 136 days 6/5/23
132 Camden Avenue 3 3 1,500 $748,880 $700,000 $466 224 days 6/2/23
109 Sprague Avenue 4 1 1,755 $749,000 $670,000 $381 143 days 6/1/23
261 Brehaut Avenue 3 1 996 $415,999 $406,000 $407 342 days 5/31/23
32 Murray Street 3 3 1,892 $799,900 $775,000 $409 210 days 5/26/23
Average: 3.5 2.8 2,069 $887,012 $846,988 $410 178 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 64
Viewing 1 - 50 of 64